Tough choice. I thought they were both around average as far as movies go, but I think I enjoyed A Whisker Away a bit more.

Caleath12 same

Yeah, both were pretty average but personally I just couldn't enjoy A Whisker Away coz of the cat-human love, imo it was kinda annoying... but at the same time I kinda liked the thing about there being whole other cat world and stuff.

...while Her Blue Sky was just a straight 6/10 (expected better from the creator of AnoHana... even went to the theatre to watch this).